Smith Official DNA Project

Smith Official DNA Project at FamilyTreeDNA-All Locations

What's New (past 30 days)



All Updates and Special Offers can be found either on the Smith DNA project blog or on Facebook.

Photos

 Thumb   Description   Linked to   Last Modified 

 
  6 Mar 2017

 
  6 Mar 2017

Individuals

 ID   Last Name, Given Name(s)   Born/Christened   Tree   Last Modified 
I77682 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 23 Mar 2017
I77684 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 23 Mar 2017
I77683 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 23 Mar 2017
I77686 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 23 Mar 2017
I74596 
Smith, Larkin 
b. 16 Nov 1821  Virginia,USA  Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 23 Mar 2017
I74598 
Smith, John 
b. 1802  Russell,Virginia,USA  Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 23 Mar 2017
I77685 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 20 Mar 2017
I48012 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 6 Mar 2017
I48011 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 6 Mar 2017
I48013 
 
   Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 6 Mar 2017

Families

 ID   Father ID   Father's Name   Mother ID   Married   Tree   Last Modified 
 F17397          Smith Smyth Schmidt Smythe Smitt 6 Mar 2017


Latest Guestbook Posts

 Subject   Ancestor   Poster   Date Created 
   2017-03-21 21:56:58
   2017-03-21 21:55:15
 Matthew Simpson Smith    jenklow 2017-03-21 21:54:59
 test    smithsworldwide 2017-01-05 09:53:28
 Smith Y DNA test    Bloodhound 2016-12-29 10:51:25
 Dorcella Sierman    Ronald Kidwell 2016-10-19 07:37:30
 david earl smith is my great granddad.thats all i know    mark richard smith 2016-10-05 15:17:26
 Caspar Schmidt, East Prussia  Martin 2016-09-23 12:22:46
 Archibald Smith    Anne Howard 2016-09-22 14:55:13
 Nancy Mustard/John Smith question    Wyona 2016-09-22 12:58:47
 B P Smith_Sarah Green Smith Clay co GA    herewegoagn 2016-09-21 16:34:36
 Jonathan Smith*s five sons    Gail (Smith) Bullock 2016-09-11 23:43:15
 Origin of our smith line    Timothy smith 2016-09-10 22:13:29
 additions to Frances Moore Smith    Eugene Daniel 2016-09-06 20:27:49
 Smith connection    Eugene Daniel 2016-09-06 20:18:13


Latest Guestbook Comments

 Comment ID   Comment 
 783 

J.M.,

I thought I would send you my email address too, sorry I forgot to include it. It's jenklow@yahoo.com.

Jenny Gaulding Low

 783 

Hi J.M.,

I just posted this in a separate post, but thought I would copy my post and send it to you. My husband is a descendant of this Matthew Simpson Smith, but you need to read my post.

This may be long, but I've been doing a lot of research over the last few days trying to put the pieces together. I had my Uncle, Earl Anderson, tested to try to trace my Anderson Family line and to join the Anderson Family Project, only to find out that we are actually Smith's!  There has been a name change somewhere down the line with my family. I also match Smith's, but I was stupid before and had my DNA tested through 23andMe, my Uncle Earl's was too, but I paid to have his tested twice. Earl Anderson Kit # 463320 is a match to these Smith's:

1) John Henry Smith born 10 Mar 1867 in Cass County, Texas, died 25 Apr 1898 in Irving, Dallas County, Texas

2) Isaac Smith born 1783 in Tennessee

3) Bennett B Smith born 1811 in North Carolina, died aft 15 Jun 1880 in possibly McNairy County, Tennessee

Those on a 1st genetic distance, these on a 2nd

4) David L Lewis born 1878 in Bledsoe, Tennessee

5) Harvey Lee Smith (No more information)

This one on a 3rd genetic distance

6) Stephen Smith (No more information)

 

 I've been trying to trace the steps of this John Henry Smith and his line. I do know that his father was James Andrew Stephen Smith who was born 1842 (1834 according to the Mortality Death Index) in Carroll County, Georgia. Carroll County, Georgia. JAS Smith is the son of Andrew J Smith born 1802 in South Carolina, USA, died 1878 in Van Zandt County, Texas (Find A Grave Memorial# 72172059), and Nancy Ann Ingram Smith born 1797 in England, died 1878 in Van Zandt County, Texas (Find A Grave Memorial# 72171977). Andrew and Nancy Smith were living in Carroll County, Georgia in 1840.

https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/1170055/person/230077414825/facts

 

The children of Andrew J and Nancy Ingram Smith are:

1) Elizabeth "Eliza" "Eliezer" Smith born 22 Feb 1822 in Carroll County, Georgia, died 11 Jan 1908 in Chandler, Van Zandt County, Texas. Married Zion Cantrell 23 Dec 1841 in Carroll County, Georgia.

2) Mary Frances "Polly" Smith born 1824 in Carroll County, Georgia, died 15 May 1872 in Davis County, Texas. Married Benjamin Franklin Cantrell on 14 Sep 1843 in Carroll County, Georgia.

3) S (May be Samuel or Simpson) Smith born 1830 in Carroll County, Georgia

4) Margaret Smith born 1832 in Carroll County, Georgia. Married George Bertrand on 19 Mar 1857 in Cass County, Texas.

5) Sarah "Sally" Smith born 1834 in Carroll County, Georgia. Married T A Gipson on 10 Aug 1871 in Cass County, Texas.

6) Martha Smith born 1836 in Carroll County, Georgia. Married M R Pettington on 2 Jan 1860 in Cass County, Texas

7) Nancy Smith born 1837 in Carroll County, Georgia. Married Thomas Collins on 14 Mar 1867 in Cass County, Texas

8) Catherine Smith born 1838 in Carroll County, Georgia, died 1894 in Van Zandt County, Texas. Married Marquis De Lafayette Fulgham on 31 Mar 1861 in Cass County, Texas.

9) James Andrew Stephen Smith born 1842 in Carroll County, Georgia, died Jul 1869 in Davis County, Texas. Married Mary Gwin on 16 May 1861 in Cass County, Texas. Mary Gwin was from Alabama.  (Cass County Marriages, 1855 - 1874, Volume 2, Page 173 - Groom listed as: Stephen Smith, Bride listed as: M. Givins? transcription error - It's M Gwin). 

Source for all of their children's Cass County, Texas Marriages:

http://files.usgwarchives.net/tx/cass/vitals/marriages/early/vol2-3.txt

 

 

 

Here is the 1850 US Census from Carroll County, Georgia. It shows Andrew and Nancy with most of their children.

http://search.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?indiv=1&dbid=8054&h=18516011&ssrc=pt&tid=71061467&pid=44235872695&usePUB=true

JAS Smith is seen with Catherine Smith (Fulgham), and sibling, S Smith (Name could be Samuel or Simpson Smith), living with their father, A (Andrew J) Smith, and mother, listed as  A Smith (Nancy Ann Ingram), a female born in 1797.It says here that Nancy was born in the Atlantic Ocean, which I thought was funny, but the 1850 Census says she was born in England. . JAS Smith died of Rheumatism in Jul 1869 in Davis County, Texas. I had seen others saying he died in 1870, but I actually looked at the document and read it, and it says "Persons who died during the Year ending June 1, 1870."

Source: U.S.Federal Census Mortality Schedules, 1850-1885 for Davis County, Texas

http://interactive.ancestry.com/8756/TXT1134_55-0293/90625?backurl=https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/1170055/person/230077414416/facts/citation/760268551292/edit/recordhttp://files.usgwarchives.net/tx/cass/vitals/marriages/early/vol2-3.txt

 

The children of JAS Smith are living with his wife, Mary Smith in Davis County, Texas in the 1870 Census and she is listed as a widow. 

 

http://search.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?indiv=1&dbid=7163&h=7637482&ssrc=pt&tid=1170055&pid=230077413436&usePUB=true

 

Mary Gwin Smith then married Thomas Brown between 1870 and 1878. They had one daughter together named Fanny Brown.

http://interactive.ancestry.com/6742/4244719-00688/10566615?backurl=https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/1170055/person/230077413436/facts/citation/760266429034/edit/record

FYI - Davis County is actually the same as Cass County, Texas. It was Cass County, renamed Davis County for about 10 years, and then renamed Cass County again. So really they never moved.


Now that I've shown you this line that my Uncle Earl Anderson has shown as a matching, this is what I stumbled upon completely by accident. Another cousin on 23andMe had asked me if I would look at my DNA matches and compare the ones I had and see which ones also showed as a match to her. I decided I would do that and check and see if they had any surnames listed to see if there were any that I recognized as ones I might know were on my tree already. I went through 50 different matches of people doing this on Sunday Night, which actually took me hours to do.

At about 3 a.m., I ran across one that had the surname of Mullins. I recognized the name as being one in my tree. So I went to double check that, and when I did, I was really blown away. I was staring at a Mullins who married a Smith who ended up in Cass County, Texas. And this was not one that I have not been looking at over the last couple of days. It's not one of Andrew's kids, or his wife, or his grandkids.

 

Rebecca Smith born 23 Jul 1786 in South Carolina, died 1865 in Colbert County, Alabama. She married James Mullins born 16 Sep 1785 in Washington, Virginia, died 11 Aug 1864 in Tuscumbia, Colbert County, Alabama. Their son, Matthew Simpson Mullins born 22 Jan 1812 in Mississippi Terrritory, what is now Tuscaloosa, Tuscaloosa County, Alabama, died 18 Mar 1866 in Cass County, Texas.

 

Matthew Simpson Mullins \ Mullens moved to Cass County, Texas in the 1850's around the same time as Andrew Smith and his family. Now since families moved together, I find it very odd that Rebecca Smith from South Carolina, died in Colbert County, which was part of Lawrence County, Alabama. If you continue to trace Andrew's line down, that some of his line lived in that area as well, such as Col. Gaines Chisholm Smith of Limestone County, Alabama. 

I don't find this a coincidence!

 

Rebecca Smith's father, is Matthew Simpson Smith. And his father is James Smith. Rebecca has 2 siblings. She has a sister names Jane "Jennie" Smith, and a brother named James Simpson Smith who was born in 1792. Andrew J Smith is only 10 more years younger. I think he is Rebecca's brother. Now, what's even crazier is that this Rebecca was already in my tree. When I looked up to see the relationship to me on Sunday night.....she is my husband's 4th great grandmother!!!!  My husband and I are cousins!  Isn't that crazy!  I was born in Alabama.  He was born in Texas. That makes it even funnier because that is where both of these families are from or lived.  And we ended up together.... of all things! I guess God really meant for us to be together!

My husband has already had his DNA tested and is part of the Lowe \ Low Family Project. Rebecca Smith is his 4th Great Grandmother on his mother's side, so I'm not sure if she would even show up in his DNA because I don't understand the DNA stuff too much. But he had the real extensive test done, not just the family finder, and because of this, we couldn't compare our DNA through GEDmatch. I have contacted a person who has had their DNA tested and posted that they are a match on Ancestry, and asked if they would compare, but I have not received a response back. I'm just asking if there is anyone out there who may be a match to this Matthew Simpson Smith or his father James Smith born 16 May 1729 in Tullyherine, Ireland, died May 1764 who may be willing to compare DNA with my Uncle Earl Anderson's DNA. 

 

I know this is long, and I thank you for taking the time to read it all. It's taken me several days to gather all of the information. I haven't seen anyone on Ancestry or any where online who has all of this information together, so maybe it will be of help to someone. I'm hoping someday I will find out how our Anderson's became Smith's. Maybe this will be a start for us.

 

Thanks for your time!

 

Jennifer "Jenny" Gaulding Low

 713 

Mr Silverheels birth name was Harold Preston Smith. Son of Alexander George Edwin Smith Sr., and Mabel Phoebe Doxtater.

 532 

test

 336 

Hello, My name is Becky Smith Morris, niece of Ronnie Smith who did our DNA testing, I handle the administration of our kit # **1018.  Ronnie, who is my unlce, is a direct line from General.  We need your help locating any and all ancestors of General's line as we have stalemated.

Ronnie a direct descendent of General Washington Smith b 1784 NC, lived Marlboro SC1800, Screvin Cnty GA 1813,d Wayne Cnty GA 1860?  He was married to Laney Wiggins Liberty Cnty GA 1818. Direct Line Archibald - Wiliam -Henry (kit **1579 - 37 markers) and - Matthew (kit **1018 -  67 markers)  Henry and Matthew were brothers but Ronnie's line is through Matthew.

I am seeing the names Simon, Benjamin,Levi, Willard appearing alot around the movement from North Carolina, South Carolina and Georgia.  But cannot put a finger on the connection.  Only connection is the DNA Group R-M269-18 where I am seeing Simon and Benjamin's name appear.  I think that I did see Levi's name once but don't remember.  They have lived next door to each other, on legal documents. etc. But still no connection as to a relationship.  Possibly brothers, cousins,father, grandfather, uncles, I don't know I cannot put the connection there. There is also the possiblity that General either had a sister who was born in 1800 SC or a daughter at the age of 16 in SC but cannot find a record.  We know that a census shows three people one being u nder age 3 female associated with General.  We also know that a female named Lucretia Smith age 18 married the brother of Laney Wiggins, Peter Wiggins around the same time that General and Laney married in Liberty Cnty GA.  Any help would be appreciated.  Dont know if the link is somewhere hidden in your info or not.  Have anyone done higher than a 67 in your group  Is that feasible to do after doing 67markers?   What is the protocol next at this point to finding information that is needed to go further back?

Open to suggestions.

Thank you

Becky Smith Morris

 238 

Land Deed

1801 • Montgomery County, Virginia, USA

Jacobs 28 Acres of Land was surveyed for him in 1801. This land was on the south fork of the Roanoke in todays FLOYD COUNTY VIRGINIA. He sold this land to Henry Shockey

Residence

1810 • Montgomery County, Virginia, USA

He is next to Rosannah SHILLING and it is not alphabetically listed. Rosannah Shilling is my Jacob SMITHs mother in Law, as stated his marriage record. Jacobs land adjoined Rosannahs as stated in his deed.

Land Deed

1817 • Montgomery County Virginia

in 1817, 80 Acres of Land Surveyed for Jacob Smith on BIG RUN a Branch of the South Fork of the Roanoke this was adjoining his own land he already had. He sold this land to Daniel Sowder

Land Deed

05 AUG 1820 • Montgomery County, Virginia, USA

Jacob and Mary sold their 28 Acres that adjoined Rosanna Shilling to Henry Shockey.

Residence

1820 • Blacksburg, Montgomery, Virginia, United States

If you look in the Tax Lists from 1812 and up you will notice there is a JR and a SENIOR our Jacob is the SENIOR. This Jacob in this Census is SR not JR.

Land

1826 • Montgomery County, Virginia, USA

Jacob Smith and wife Polly sold their 50 Acres to Peter Guerrant Jr. on the South Fork of the Roanoke.

Tax List

1829 • Pike County, Kentucky, USA

He is listed in the Tax List of Pike County Kentucky for 1829

Residence

1830 • Pike, Kentucky, USA

Residence

1840 • Pike, Kentucky, United States

TAX

1841 • Cabell, Virginia, USA

He is listed in the 1841 Tax List for Cabell County Virginia (West Virginia)

Wayne County West Virginia was created in 1842...Wayne County and Cabell County have a confusing boundary especially up near Beech Fork State Park... Most residence call the area Cabell/Wayne

TAX

1842 • Wayne County, West Virginia, USA

Land Deed

18 Mar 1848 • Cabell County, West Virginia, USA

Jacob Smith and wife Polly sold 45 Acres on Tory Branch of Beech Fork of Twelve Pole to Jacob Smith.

Residence

1850 • District 66, Wayne, Virginia, USA

Residence

1860 • Cabell, Virginia, USA

This area became West Virginia 2 years later.

 

 714 

Hi, Debra:  I am a descendant of Eliza and Sam's sister, Samantha.  I would love to correspond.  My email is:  tonyamaddux@hotmail.com.  Please contact me.   Thanks!!

 

 

 788 

My earliest confirmed ancestor is Robert Smith, born 1816 in Franklin County VA. His father may have been John Smith, and his father Martin Smith. Then Martin's father may have been Martin Sr., born around 1742. Therein lies a total brick wall for my research. No one knows who preceded Martin Sr. but I have surmised that there may be a connection to a line of Martin (last name), as that would answer how he and his son had that first name. Anyway, some of my DNA connections put me in South Carolina as well. Thus the motivation to write this reply to your post. None of this stuff is easy to unravel, but some of what you wrote seems compelling to say the least.

 

 326 

Additional Mauldin information:

See this page:

http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Space:Mauldin_North_Carolina_Timeline

Amazingly, they have Kitt Smith marrying Mary Mauldin. I believe he was actually her son.

To see the relevance of the Mauldin surname with Group 8's ancestry, enter (accurately, please) the entire yDNA marker sequence into ySearch.org's search program. You will see NPEs for a Mauldin and Coker line. No coincidence.

Christopher Smith

Group R-M269-9 Contact

 326 

Regarding Mary Mauldin, d/o Rucker Mauldin:

I found a preview of a book on Google Books that, amazingly, has a snippet that seems to provide an alternative hypothesis on who Mary Mauldin married.

It is titled "Wills-deeds and Family Histories, Volume 1". It's author is our very favorite! Linda G. Cheek!! Yes!

https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Mary+Mauldin%22+%22Christopher+Smith%22+%22+%22Harmon+Smith%22&es_sm=122&source=lnms&tbm=bks&sa=X&ved=0CA4Q_AUoAWoVChMI5o3t7O-QyAIVASweCh1akwqw&biw=1920&bih=979

The first snippet says (I've stylized the font for emphasis): 

Obedience Smith (Biddy) d/o Wade Smith who married Mary Mauldin —Mary Mauldin d/o Rucker Mauldin and Ann Miller Moore ... Govan Smith s/o Harmon Smith need proof Much work has to be done on these Smiths in order to prove who the ... (believe youngest child) also called Kitt Smith b. ca 1786 m. supposedly Martha Mauldin b. between 1780-1790 Christopher Smith and Thomas Smith were in ...

Again, I have not modified the text of the snippit, only stylized where I thought important.

Now who among us has this book at the ready??

Christopher Smith

Group R-M269-9 Contact

 326 

Further, please see the following highlighted Google Books search result for information on Christopher Smith and Catherine Snelson's line.

https://books.google.com/books?id=HDMyAQAAMAAJ&pg=RA1-PA150&lpg=RA1-PA150&dq=%22Another+Smith+Family%22+%22William+and+Mary%22&source=bl&ots=zmQeY8DzGM&sig=v4npgIIdAVyq70PisrY24RYk8EM&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CB4Q6AEwAGoVChMIkuuMu9yQyAIVR6weCh2HnQtn#v=onepage&q=%22Another%20Smith%20Family%22%20%22William%20and%20Mary%22&f=false

 

Please note that Francis Marion Smith's line is not mentioned, but an Ambrose Smith is as a brother of a John O. Smith, a cousin to John Snelson Smith.

 

Christopher Smith

Group R-M269-9 Contact

 326 

Argumentation for relatedness of Frances W "Frank" Smith (SWW Group R-M269-9) to lineage of James H. Smith and Susannah (Dowis) Chapman
 
Earliest to most recent records:
 
1867
James A Smith and Elizabeth Winkler are married in White Co, GA, 10 Nov 1867.
 
--
 
1870
 
--
 
James A. Smith - Age 23 - Born abt 1847 in SC
(Family 427, Subdivision 135, White Co, GA: Page 49/93 on Ancestry.com)***
Elizabeth (Winkler)*
Mary J. Smith - Age 1 - Born abt 1869**
 
James (H.) Smith - Age 74 - Born abt 1796 in SC
Susannah Smith - Age 64 - Born abt 1806 in SC
(Family 438, Subdivision 135, White Co, GA: Page 51/93 on Ancestry.com)***
 
*We know this is Elizabeth Winkler because this Smith family is living directly next to TWO Winkler families.
**Mary J. Smith ties into 1880 record.
***James A. Smith and Susannah Smith are in the same subdivision only 11 families apart.
 
--
 
1880
 
Susannah Smith - Age 75 - Born abt 1805 in S. Carolina
(House 133, Family 136, Mossy Creek Militia District, White Co, GA: Page 15/24 on Ancestry.com)
James A. Smith - Age 33 - Born abt 1847 in S. Carolina
Elizabeth (Winkler)*
Mary Smith - Age 11 - Born abt 1869**
(House 134, Family 137, Mossy Creek Militia District, White Co, GA: Page 15/24 on Ancestry.com)
 
**See 1870 record for person's previous entry.
 
On page 15/24 of this 1880 census record, we also find "Larence Smith", age 36, born abt 1844 in S. Carolina, and his family. His wife's name is Margaret. Laurence Smith's lineage appears to be easily linked to James H. Smith and Susannah Dowis Chapman by earlier censuses. (I will not show this work here.)
 
--
 
1890
This official census record was probably destroyed, as many records of 1890 were. The partial 1890 census on Ancestry.com does not show a James A Smith listed.
 
--
 
1891
 
James Smith and Martha Allen are married in White Co, GA, 8 Nov 1891
 
--
 
1900
James A. Smith - Age 52 - Born abt Sep 1847 in GA? (I can't resolve why he would have stated he was born in GA when previously he states SC).
(House 138, Family 138, Blue Ridge, White, GA: Page 7/10 on Ancestry.com)
Martha Allen (James A. Smith's second marriage)
Francis W Smith - Age 2 - Born abt 1898
 
--
 
(James' two marriages (Winkler-1, Allen-2) are well documented by a descendant and both marriage records can be found in the White Co, GA archives)
 
Onward from 1900, the Francis W Smith line is easy to follow with little confusion.
 
Francis Marion Smith is connected to the line of Harman Smith and we can see via a comparison on SmithsWorldWide.org that my group (R-M269-9) and Harmon Smith's group (R-M269-8) do not match even distantly. This is based upon the claim of Harmon’s line by one of the Group 8 members.
 
Keep in mind, I have found my Raglands and Lipscombs in Group 8’s trees, and I know for certain that a 66/67 yDNA match of mine is descended from the Raglands and Lipscombs. This was never addressed by Group 8.
 
 
Christopher A. Smith

 327 

Please add me since my group seems to be the most closely related.

Mike

 750 

Hi, James

I've added your facts to the Smith tree system now and you are welcome to register if you'd like to add or edit infomraiton for it. There are so many Smiths that we rely on people who don't see their partiuclar one to send in a tree and I'm really glad that you have posted. 

 326 

Few things to consider: First, matches in the group are made on the basis of 37 markers or more, or if there are circumstances such as 2 brothers that post. 12 marker matches are so prevalent and general that they are not useful for narrowing down potential matches. Second, as I mentioned to you previously, the person someone puts in the Most Distant Ancestor field is doing it based on their own attestation. That's why you see, so often, ancestral locations all over the map. As FTDNA says "To validate our Reference Population set we tested them against a list of well studied benchmark groups whose ancestral background in the literature has been well attested. Additionally we also cross-checked against individuals with attested provenance within the GeneByGene DNA database." https://www.familytreedna.com/learn/family-finder-pages/myorigins-methodology/ - Given that second sentence, the attested provenance would be someone saying that he or she believes the origin to be X." 

Third, if you believe you have source documents to prove a lineage, you need to supply it here rather than refer to trees or autosomal data, which beyond several generations is very difficult to triangulate and depends upon solid trees, since one cannot know which surname/person is indicated by an autosomal match. 

Here's what happened, specifically, with Christopher Smith. Christopher Smith is one of those lines that quite a few people have as an ancestor, and, as it happened, there were at least 3 main groups that did not match, that all claimed him. We, as a very large discussion group, looked at the lineages, source documents, and determined that one of the participants in particular had a very good, sourced claim for the line. Every single person in all 3 groups agreed that he did and therefore, he at this point has the claim to Christopher Smith. If someone comes along with better documentation that can lay a paper trail claim to knock this group off its throne, that's fine, but the above does not meet that criteria. I am going to invite the group to come over and make their own comments as they would like, but have to say, frankly, that to demand that people must change their lineage when a whole lot of thought and effort has gone into this so far, and on the basis of one MDA ancestor at 12 markers that believes he has a Polish ancestor, will not cause a change. What I suggest you do is list a line of descent with source documents as proof.

I am glad, however, that you have expressed yourself here, this gives opportunity for others to corroborate what you say, add more, or challenge, so it's good.